ALL REVIEWS

Mission Name Knife Fight File Knifefight.zip
Author TS Bandit_1 Release Date 12/07/99
Players 1 Campaign No
Mission Type Defence Addons None
Reviewer Kellan Review Date 12/26/99
User Rating 79% Staff Rating 3.0 Stars

Description
You must ensure the Aquitane and GTCv actium reach the Epsilon Pegasi jump node. The shivans have other ideas.

Storyline: 3.0 Stars
The storyline of this mission, while nothing special ties in nicely with the main Freespace 2 campaign and uses several familiar ship names. The briefing is fairly well written with few errors. However, the icons are terribly squashed up and, as a result you canÂ’t see a thing. There arenÂ’t enough messages in the mission, which makes it feel disjointed. The debriefing also has a few spelling errors, but is otherwise okay.

Balance: 2.5 Stars
You shouldnÂ’t have a great deal of trouble saving both of your capital ships in this mission. The Shivan bombers usually arrive too far away to launch their bombs and have little fighter escort. The enemy capital ships arrive with their vulnerable flanks exposed to the might of the HecateÂ’s forward beam batteries. The loadout for the mission is also too varied and powerful, though at least someone removed the multiplayer variants. The most disappointing thing about the balance of the mission is that with the ships available this mission could have been made very challenging.

Design: 2.5 Stars
The design of this mission is nothing special. Waypoints are used and beam cannons all work, but there are no directives and no background either. There isn’t anything very complicated that has been made in the s-exps, either. Some of the events could actually have been handled with the departure cues of the ships, and how the author knew which s-exp he was writing is a mystery, as they’re all ‘Event name’. On a positive note, the positioning of the Lilith cruiser is very strategic.

Gameplay: 3.0 Stars
Gameplay isn’t too bad really, considering the other problems, although you will be leaving a lot of the fighting to the capital ships unless you choose a bomber (which you can load with Helios bombs). The mission does feel a bit empty and a bit pointless, though. There could have been several ‘motivational’ messages from Terran Command.

Other Thoughts:
The capital ships are pretty poorly placed. If the Tantalus came at the Aquitaine head on, and the corvettes dived down from above they would do a lot more damage.

Bottom Line: An average defence mission with a whole lot of beam action.
Highs: ItÂ’s actually fun for a while.
Lows: Placement of the enemy ships is awful in some cases.
Rating: 3.0 Stars
User Rating: 79%


This site was designed for 800x600 resolution and 16-bit color, so use at least this resolution and color depth.
Site was tested using Internet Explorer and Netscape, versions 4 and up. Use other browsers at your own risk.

All content on this site is produced here with the permission of the original author.
All content is NOT to be reproduced on other sites without written permission from Volition Watch IN ADVANCE.
Site design: Ben "Remora" Dekarske, June 2001. Copyright 1998-2001 Volition Watch Archives.