ALL REVIEWS

Mission Name Scragglers File scragglers.FSM
Author WildWolf Release Date 06/27/98
Players 1 Campaign No
Mission Type Dogfight, Assault Addons None
Reviewer Zarathud Review Date 09/08/98
User Rating 47% Staff Rating 2.0 Stars

Description
Player is sent out to renovate the Asteroid Belt of some Shivan scragglers. Suddenly, a Shivan Freighter carrying an unknown cargo arrives with an odd wing of fighter protection...

Storyline: 1.5 Stars
Clear out Shivan fighters located in the asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter. With Lucifer being destroyed in the Sol Jump Node, you can expect a few Shivans to be lying around. However, the entire second portion of the mission was confusing. Where did the freighter come from and why did it have an "odd wing of fighter protection"? This confusion isn't resolved, since the debriefing only suggests that the unscannable cargo container would help GTA Intelligence.

Balance: 3.5 Stars
Alpha will be limited to a GTF Ulysses fighter armed with some combination of Avenger/Prometheus cannons and Interceptor missiles. The maneuverable Ulysses is an understandable choice for the asteroid field. With its light hull, the Ulysses is well-suited to fight Shivan Basilisks and Scorpions, as well as the other "odd" defenders.

Design: 2.0 Stars
The asteroid field is incredibly dense, resulting in some incredibly tense dogfighting. Although the asteroid field is long, it is only 2000 meters wide. Since the Ulysses can quickly cover this distance, the visual effect is ruined. The narrow width also results in too close of a ship placement for wingmen and the first Shivan wave. Even 1400 meters away and in an asteroid field, these Shivans are just too close to give pilots a chance to orient themselves. <p> Difficulty levels are implemented in this mission, so those who play on "hard" or higher will have to target the Shivans visually instead of using your sensors. Now I'd call <u>that</u> difficult, which is a nice touch. <p> However, the transport events suffered from problems. The bonus objective to "protect the cargo" is immediately satisfied when the transport arrives. Given the dressing down you receive in debriefing for failing the objective, this should be an "invalid" secondary objective that later becomes "valid." Also, the transport doesn't do well in the asteroid field: its speed will vary from 35+ m to 9 m as asteroids block its waypoint route. It will finish the waypoint path at the edge of the asteroid field, too close to avoid collissions. As a result, the Shivan cargo will be in as much danger from the asteroids as from your stray fire. <p> Finally, the "odd wing of fighter protection" appeared to be a bug until I checked the storyline given on Xanadu's archive. I realize that the ship choice was deliberate, but there were no messages in the mission commenting on the oddity.

Gameplay: 2.0 Stars
All the fighters fly using captain AI, so every ship flies well even in the dense asteroid field. The enemy will get in close and use asteroids for cover. The result is an excellent dogfight, where all the ships are zipping in, out and around the ever-present asteroids. <p> However, the fun ends when Alpha must take out the transport. It is difficult to destroy the Shivan transport without severely damaging the cargo. A trick, however, forces the transport to undock with the cargo. But the cargo will remain inside the dense asteroid field, and asteroids destroyed the cargo every time I was able to avoid destroying it.

Other Thoughts:
Some nice touches, but also a few aggravating problems dealing with the transport portion of the mission. I'd have been much happier if the author had decided to stick to the dogfight. As it is, I suspect the mission expanded on its own as new FRED features were discovered.

Bottom Line: An entertaining dogfight in a densely-packed asteroid field, until you begin a buggy, unsatisfying transport assault. Play the first part, then jump out when you have to deal with the freighter.
Highs: Asteroids! Well-balanced dogfight between Ulysses and enemy fighters. Mission varies with difficulty settings.
Lows: Transport assault aggravates. Confusing story that is never explained.
Rating: 2.0 Stars
User Rating: 47%


This site was designed for 800x600 resolution and 16-bit color, so use at least this resolution and color depth.
Site was tested using Internet Explorer and Netscape, versions 4 and up. Use other browsers at your own risk.

All content on this site is produced here with the permission of the original author.
All content is NOT to be reproduced on other sites without written permission from Volition Watch IN ADVANCE.
Site design: Ben "Remora" Dekarske, June 2001. Copyright 1998-2001 Volition Watch Archives.