ALL REVIEWS

Mission Name Preliminary Assault File PA.fsm
Author Matthew Kowaleski Release Date 11/05/98
Players 1 Campaign No
Mission Type Attack Addons none
Reviewer Ouroboros Review Date 11/10/98
User Rating 55% Staff Rating 2.5 Stars

Description
A preliminary assualt on a mutinions depot.

Storyline: 2.0 Stars
Not <i>too</i> bad in conception, PA envisions a preliminary assault on a Shivan cargo depot as a prelude to invading Shivan space. However, the briefing is rather below average, with a lot of spelling and grammar errors. Also, the icons are badly placed, ships that are actually Ulysses are represented as Lokis, and the Wing icons are never used. Finally, in the briefing and debriefing, the word "you" isn't used. Instead, "u" is subsituted. Once or twice, this error is okay, but throughout the mission? FRED isn't an IRC chat, folks.

Balance: 2.0 Stars
Weapons selection is sufficient, permitting the use of Avengers, Prometheuses, Banshees, Pheonix Vs, Stillettos, and some other missles. However, I must complain that there are not nearly enough missles of the more common variety - more than a few of my ships didn't get the Hornet/Interceptor combo I wanted. In addition, only 4 each of the Ulysses, Athena, (Why? There aren't any Tsunamis or Harbingers) and Hercules fighters. Ugh. For the most part, the two sides are very well balanced... but the Dragons have got to go. If there had been no Dragon fighters, I would have won easily, but with the two (they respawn once, making 4 total) present, I died soon. My wingmen helped me dispatch the first two, but by the time the second wave came, I was down to one allied Ulysses. Needless to say, I went splat.

Design: 3.0 Stars
The design isn't bad at all. The events are well done, as is the Objectives programming. The time between waves is properly long, discounting the artificial effects usually seen. Overall, there is nothing wrong with PA from a technical perspective.

Gameplay: 2.0 Stars
However, the mission is overall easy, except for the thrice-damned Dragons. The little unprintable buggers just chew me up... and otherwise, things aren't quite hard enough. Adding just one more Cain (NOT ANY LILLITHS) would fix the easiness part, I think, but the Dragons just have to go.

Other Thoughts:
Wow! Someone daring to use a Cain and not a Lillith! Could this be a sign of sanity returning?

Bottom Line: Close, but no cigar. Whoops, this isn't an intern!
Highs: An overall good design, no technical issues (this is actually quite rare... sad, isn't it?)
Lows: Difficulty without Dragons would be a bit too low, with them it's WAY too hard.
Rating: 2.5 Stars
User Rating: 55%


This site was designed for 800x600 resolution and 16-bit color, so use at least this resolution and color depth.
Site was tested using Internet Explorer and Netscape, versions 4 and up. Use other browsers at your own risk.

All content on this site is produced here with the permission of the original author.
All content is NOT to be reproduced on other sites without written permission from Volition Watch IN ADVANCE.
Site design: Ben "Remora" Dekarske, June 2001. Copyright 1998-2001 Volition Watch Archives.